When Your Child Favours One Parent

Since A discovered that Momma and Papa Bear were completely separate entities to her, she has become my shadow. As soon as she started crawling, I would hear a gentle tip tip tapping on the wooden floors as she followed me. When she learned to walk, she would waddle wherever Momma Bear went. And now that she has mastered running and shouting, I hear a chorus of “Mommy, wait for me!” anytime I try to leave the room. I don’t mind my ever-fixed shadow being glued to me as I make my way from room to room – despite it being mildly inconvenient at times. What is a challenge, is the effect this parental preference has on B. Do you have a child who favours one parent over the other?

The other night B was tucking A and her beloved Duck into bed, as he does every single night. The look of pure and beautiful love he clearly and honestly has for A struck me. He had a smile and happiness in the gleam of his eye that simply spoke of love and pride and my heart melted. I have seen this look a lot since the very moment she was born.

When your child favours one parent over heaven's hill parenting blog Ireland
Since day one B has been protective and loving. A is his pride and joy

The Best of Friends

B is A’s best friend. She laughs and plays the most with him. They have games that only they can play together. They have a language that only they understand. She greets him from work with such love and affection. He understands her inside and out – he should! She is practically his duplicate in looks and personality! She loves him as much as he loves her but she rarely cries after him or chooses him over me.

When your child favours one parent over heaven's hill parenting blog Ireland
B and A are absolutely the best of friends regardless of the moments she chooses Momma over Papa Bear

She has had numerous meltdowns because I have simply indulged in going to the bathroom on my own (I realise I rescinded this right as soon as she was born but we can live in hope!) or popped out to the shops for all of half an hour. On one especially difficult day, B sent me a video of an extremely upset A as I hurried around the New Year Sales. Thankfully this was the worst scenario and we’ve managed to avoid another situation as strong as this but we are aware that it could happen again. It was a very difficult few hours for B. Admittedly, by the time I got home, everything was fine but the hurt and upset in B’s face said it all.

Choosing Sides – Gaining Control

Toddlers are not expected to understand their place in the world yet. They are only getting to grips with having a mind of their own. Saying no is the biggest control and most overwhelming power they have.

But this is a side of parenting that is not advertised in the “Let’s Have a Baby: Guide to the World”. And in reality we don’t exactly think we will be the snubbed parent. It’s not easy on B who regardless of A’s actions beautifully comforts and loves her. I’ll be honest I’ve yet to be snubbed so I can’t exactly relate but can appreciate how B feels when I’m given preferential treatment.

We have spent countless hours talking about this behaviour and how it can be rectified or to help A stay connected with Papa Bear (and possibly disconnect from Momma Bear for at least half an hour a day. Too much to ask?) but the truth of the matter is that there is no fix.

They say, and by they I mean psychologists on the internet, that it is a positive thing.

  • The child feels connected enough with you that they feel they can jilt you at any second.
  • It’s a sign of emotional and cognitive growth.
  • It helps them to assert their independence.
  • It encourages decision making skills.
  • It’s a phase and all toddlers go through it.
  • Remember, it’s not personal.

Saying that it’s a phase, it’s not personal and that A is learning does nothing to appease B and I completely understand this. How long will this phase last? It’s been on and off for 2 years as it is.

Not Always and Not Forever

It’s not every interaction and it’s not every day but B is usually the parent to be pushed away, B is the parent to get angry at, and B is the one who hears no the most from A. In saying that, B and A have amazing one-to-one days together when I am at work or away with business and B is off work. On these occasions, she rarely pines after me or even looks for me. In fact when I come home, she doesn’t particularly want to see me on those days and is very hands-on with B. There are times when I am beyond exhausted and A happily and lovingly plays with Papa Bear and revels in his attention.

When your child favours one parent over heaven's hill parenting blog Ireland
They take a lot of selfies my two

These rejection moments are temporary but routinely happen. Despite everything that B tries, A will choose me over him nine times out of ten. The hurt and rejection is real. How does the suffering parent overcome this?

The Wonderful World of the Internet

The wonderful experts of the internet have action plans for parents dealing with the preferential parent treatment. B does them all naturally, with or without success, he does everything he can in his power to appease and show his love to his daughter. No matter how many no’s he hears he will always try.

  • He gets down on the floor and asks A if he can play with her rather than assuming she would play with him.
  • He tells her he loves her consistently and that he misses her when he’s at work.
  • He gives her space when she wants and needs it.
  • He backs off when she only wants Momma Bear.
  • He asks her to help him with special tasks like collecting the milk from the gate on a Saturday morning – she always obliges.
  • He has special one on one time with her.

What to do, what to do?

We know things will change. We know there may be a day when I am no longer in favour. But until then, it’s trial and error. Until then, there will be days or even just simple moments when A chooses me over B. As frustrating and upsetting it is, we know it won’t last forever.

Until then, keep doing what you’re doing B. You’re an amazing Papa Bear. I tell you this all the time. Because it’s true. And I know A believes it too. Regardless of the moments when you may be shunned, when it may seem like A doesn’t want or need you, remember that she does. Remember that you are her best friend. Remember that she truly does love you.

And hey, it’s a phase!

When your child favours one parent over heaven's hill parenting blog Ireland
A is attempting “I Love You” in sign language here 🙂

11 thoughts on “When Your Child Favours One Parent

  • August 22, 2016 at 9:16 am

    Tell your husband not to worry or be upset, we have had this with everyone of my girls and it really is a phase that doesn’t last very long.
    Alex recently posted…The Daddy Tag ChallengeMy Profile

    • August 22, 2016 at 9:58 am

      Thanks Alex. It can feel like a never ending issue and it’s heartbreaking to see the hurt on B’s face. They have an amazing relationship though and that will never change

  • August 23, 2016 at 8:36 am

    Firstly, a wonderful honest post. Secondly, this really changes over time – my three all went through it and now they are older they come to us both for different needs and you learn to accept that as a parent too. It will get so much easier for B xx #DreamTeam

  • August 23, 2016 at 8:43 am

    I used to be the go to parent but hubby changed jobs and took over more child care & it is more even now. I think this will change but your man sounds like a wonderful daddy! #DreamTeam

  • August 24, 2016 at 11:27 am

    I have a feeling that as my little one gets older, he is going to favour Daddy more than Mummy. I’ve just gone back to work, so Daddy does nursery pick up and bedtime and I can already see the shift in arrangement in a short space of time. He’s still young, so not really favouring one over the other, but I expect it to happen as he gets older. I’m trying to prepare myself for it and this is a great reassuring post – it is just a phase! #DreamTream

  • August 27, 2016 at 11:40 pm

    We have lived this in a very real way. Nip#1 was and still is in many ways an absolute mummy’s girl. Poor daddy didn’t get much of a look in and like that, they had a great relationship but she would sometimes be quite hurtful to him. He got a whole lot of ‘I don’t want you, I want mummy’. Since Ross has become a SAHD their relationship has come on in leaps and bounds. That said I always told him that it would change in time anyway – I’m sure when she is screaming ‘I hate you mom’ (I dread that flipping day) she will be all loved up with daddy. I expect it will be the teenage years so I’m happy to milk it now.

    The part I really didn’t like was the sheer hurt I could see after he had been told for the millionth time that he wasn’t the one she wanted. It’s a very difficult situation and they are too small to understand how upsetting it is. As adults we are meant to be able to use our logic to understand this isn’t personal….but yet it is, especially when Daddy is so hands on and goes out of his way to have fun and spend quality time with her.

    When I googled this and I did many time I didn’t find too much so thanks for posting. Getting this information out is important and reassuring for others who are going through the same.
    The Missus recently posted…Mama – The one who goes to work My Profile

    • August 28, 2016 at 3:36 pm

      Thank you so much Mel. It makes it easier knowing that others have felt the exact same way as B. We’ve just had a week off work and A has literally been following B everywhere which is really unusal hut beautiful. We expect when we go back to work tomorrow it will be back to normal with my shadow. He absolutely loves A so much and craves her to want him. We know the day will come but until then despite how heartbreaking the rejection moments are he’ll suffer through them. It’s so great to know that the connection Ross has with your little ones has grown stronger since becoming a SAHD.

  • September 3, 2016 at 12:25 pm

    hahha… My sister gave birth to a baby girl last September and her birthday is coming soon. Reading your post I can’t help but think back on the days my sister told me that once her father is home she doesn’t look for mommy anymore! hahaha Your posts are beautiful. I will ask my sister to read them too.

    • September 5, 2016 at 4:58 pm

      It’s so interesting how babies and children go through phases of favouriting one parent. Really makes the left out parent feel strange if not rejected

  • December 3, 2016 at 7:11 am

    Really nice post. We’re going through the same thing with our 22 month old, Little Man. The difference is that he’s all about daddy. Our 4 year old Fidget was the same when she was younger. But as she has grown she now prioritises her needs and approaches each parent as required. Fidget is still a bit of a daddy’s girl, but has now learnt to play one parent off the other. They’re just natural phases that most children go through. It is hard on the parent who is being sidelined, though. But it doesn’t last forever. I’m sure you are both great parents.

    • December 6, 2016 at 3:23 pm

      It’s quite interesting, but since I’ve written this post, A has done a complete U turn and is now all about Daddy. It’s quite funny when he realised he can’t go to the bathroom on his own anymore. It’s amazing how children grasp on to parent. I look forward to the day she plays us off one another 😀 Thanks for commenting David.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.